Shelf staples

Maya Hennessey

@nighttrainmaya

9Items

1Likes

This is the current state of the bourbon shelf that lives between my kitchen and my Kindle: the bottles I reach for when a Celtics game goes late, when a product launch goes sideways, or when I’m trying to decode a weird plot twist with Coltrane in the background. Some of these are easy grocery-store grabs, some I squirrel away when I see them, but every one has earned its square inch of cabinet real estate and at least one long, probably overthought tasting note on my phone.

See all 9 items Follow Maya HennesseyOpen in app

The list

Showing 1–9 of 9

Shelf staples — 9 items
Name	Style / Proof	Best for	My take
1Buffalo Trace Bourbon	Straight bourbon, 90 proof	Weeknight sips and introducing bourbon-curious friends	This is the T-pass of bourbons: unglamorous on paper, weirdly indispensable in real life. Caramel, a little orange peel, just enough oak to feel grown-up. I pour this when I want something I don’t have to think about until the book gets boring.
2Eagle Rare 10 Year	10-year straight bourbon, 90 proof	Slow Friday pours when you actually closed your laptop on time	Vanilla, cherry, and this dry, almost dark-chocolate finish that makes me slow down whether I want to or not. When I can find it at a sane price, it’s my ‘reward for answering all my emails like an adult’ bottle.
3Four Roses Single Barrel	Single barrel bourbon, 100 proof	Solo pours with jazz and no Slack notifications	High-rye, high-personality. Lots of baking spice and fruit; it’s like drinking the good part of apple pie without the sugar crash. Each barrel’s a little different, which scratches the collector itch without requiring a second mortgage.
4Elijah Craig Small Batch	Small batch bourbon, 94 proof	Backup ‘house pour’ when the Buffalo Trace is mysteriously gone	Toasty oak, brown sugar, a bit of peanut shell — comfortable in the same way as that hoodie you pretend you don’t wear to Zoom calls. I reach for this when I’m half-reading, half-watching highlights and fully ignoring my to-do list.
5Russell’s Reserve 10 Year	10-year small batch bourbon, 90 proof	Long catch-up conversations that keep refilling themselves	This tastes like Wild Turkey 101 put on a blazer. Still has that Turkey spice, but smoothed out with more vanilla and oak. It’s an easy crowd-pleaser, especially with friends who claim they’re ‘more of a wine person.’
6Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style	Straight bourbon, 115 proof	When the plot twist hits and you need something with backbone	Chocolate, dark fruit, and a little burnt sugar in the best way — like the corner brownie piece. Despite the proof, it’s surprisingly sippable if you’re not shy about a little heat. My go-to when the Celtics go to OT and I’m in too deep to switch to water
7Maker’s Mark 46	Stave-finished wheated bourbon, 94 proof	Soft, slightly fancy-feeling pours with good takeout	All the friendly, bready sweetness of regular Maker’s, but with extra vanilla and baking spice from the staves. It’s my sushi-and-bourbon pairing bottle, which I will defend as a valid life choice until proven otherwise.
8Knob Creek 9 Year	9-year small batch bourbon, 100 proof	Classic Old Fashioneds and mildly existential Sunday nights	Big oak, roasted nuts, and a little maple syrup vibe. It’s sturdy enough to stand up in cocktails but interesting enough neat. I pour this when I’m reorganizing my bookshelf instead of dealing with my inbox.
9Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon	Straight bourbon, 90.4 proof	Sharing with mixed company (bourbon nerds and casual sippers)	Balanced in that ‘everyone will think this is good’ way: caramel, citrus, a little oak tannin to keep it from feeling like dessert. This is the bottle I bring when I don’t know who else will be at the table.

Conversation

All 1 posts

Join the conversation