Shelf bourbons

Marcus Hale

@eastsideengineer

6Items

0Likes

These are the bottles that have survived my friends, my moves, and at least three landlord inspections. All of them have spent time on my actual shelf in a one-bedroom walk-up where the smoke alarm is more of a suggestion. Some are easy pours after a Knicks loss, some are what I reach for when the MTA has personally offended me. None of them are perfect. That’s the fun part.

See all 6 items Follow Marcus HaleOpen in app

The list

Showing 1–6 of 6

Shelf bourbons — 6 items
Name	Distillery	Style	Approx proof	Typical NYC price	My take
1Buffalo Trace Bourbon	Buffalo Trace Distillery, Kentucky	Straight bourbon	90	$30–$40 a bottle; $12–$14 a pour	The house red of bourbon. Shows up everywhere from Midtown steakhouses to East Village dive shelves. Caramel, a little orange peel, nothing jagged. I buy it when I don’t want to think, which is more often than I admit.
2Four Roses Single Barrel	Four Roses Distillery, Kentucky	Single barrel bourbon	100	$50–$60 a bottle; $15–$18 a pour	The one I pour for people who say they “don’t really drink bourbon.” Floral nose, cherry and baking spice, then a neat little rye snap at the end. Tastes like someone actually thought about balance for once in this town.
3Wild Turkey Rare Breed	Wild Turkey Distillery, Kentucky	Barrel-proof bourbon	112–116 (varies by batch)	$60–$70 a bottle; $18–$22 a pour	This is the express track of my shelf: loud, fast, a little reckless. Big vanilla, brown sugar, and a decent punch of oak. Not subtle, but neither is the B train at rush hour and I still ride it.
4Elijah Craig Small Batch	Heaven Hill Distillery, Kentucky	Small batch bourbon	94	$30–$40 a bottle; $12–$15 a pour	The weeknight engineer bourbon. Nutty, toasty, a little cinnamon. If I’m answering work emails after 10 p.m., this is probably in the glass, judging me but gently.
5Russell’s Reserve 10 Year	Wild Turkey Distillery, Kentucky	Age-stated small batch bourbon	90	$40–$50 a bottle; $14–$16 a pour	Reads like Rare Breed’s older, calmer sibling. Toffee, oak, a little leather. This is what I pour when the Knicks somehow win by 20 and I’m trying to process joy responsibly.
6Old Forester 1920 Prohibition Style	Old Forester Distilling Co., Kentucky	High-proof bourbon	115	$65–$75 a bottle; $20–$24 a pour	Chocolate, dark fruit, and oak in a trench coat. Drinks like dessert that decided to hit back. I keep it for snow days and overtime games that go somewhere weird.