1 Buffalo Trace | Straight bourbon | 40% | £28–£35 a bottle | Weeknight sipper and first pour of the night | 4-4-2 of bourbon: classic, balanced, does everything pretty well without showboating. If a bar has only one bourbon, I secretly hope it’s this. |
|---|
2 Four Roses Small Batch | Small batch bourbon | 45% | £38–£45 a bottle | Sharing with mixed-experience whisky mates | Flexible midfielder. Enough floral and fruit notes to keep the nerds happy, smooth enough that your non-whisky mate doesn’t feel two-footed on the first sip. |
|---|
3 Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon | Straight bourbon | 43.2% | £32–£40 a bottle | House Old Fashioned and Manhattans | Set-piece specialist. In a neat glass it’s fine, but mix it and suddenly you’re wondering why you ever used anything else for an Old Fashioned. |
|---|
4 Eagle Rare 10 Year | Aged single barrel style bourbon | 45% | £55–£70 a bottle | Slow weekend sipping | Feels like watching a 2–1 away win in silence after the final whistle. Calm, a bit contemplative, loads of toffee and orange peel if you actually pay attention. |
|---|
5 Bulleit Bourbon Frontier Whiskey | High-rye bourbon | 45% | £28–£35 a bottle | Whisky sours and backyard barbecue nights | Presses high, lives on the wings. Spicy, dryish, very mixable. I rarely sip it neat, but it’s my go-to when someone says, “Make something fun with bourbon.” |
|---|
6 Elijah Craig Small Batch | Small batch, oak-forward bourbon | 47% | £42–£50 a bottle | Neat pours after a long day | Big lad at centre-back. Lots of oak, toast, vanilla, bit of smoke round the edges. Not subtle, but sometimes you just want to feel like you’re drinking actual wood. |
|---|
7 Knob Creek 9 Year | Aged small batch bourbon | 50% | £45–£55 a bottle | One-and-done late-night dram | This is extra time in a glass. Rich, heavy, proper flavour bomb. You don’t need more than one, and if you do, you probably weren’t checking the scoreboard. |
|---|
8 Russell’s Reserve 10 Year | Age-stated bourbon | 45% | £45–£55 a bottle | Slow chats and overthinking life choices | Bit like that veteran playmaker who still sees passes no one else spots. Layers of vanilla, cherry, spice – not the loudest, but seriously rewarding if you give it time. |
|---|