Book vs film arguments
List · 4 items

Book vs film arguments

Freya NkemeluFreya Nkemelu · 0 likes
4 items
ListMovies · Entertainment

Book vs film arguments

Freya Nkemelu
@freyan_studies
4Items
0Likes

Every item here is a film I've dragged someone to see at the Peckhamplex (or occasionally BFI Southbank when I'm feeling fancy), and every single one sparked a proper row about whether the page beat the screen. I work with pictures for a living so I notice when an adaptation gets the casting right and the cover wrong, if you know what I mean. Bring popcorn and your fighting spirit — this list has ended at least two friendships and one board game night.

The list

Rank
Book vs film arguments — 4 items
NameCommentFilmBook or FilmAddressCity
1Wuthering HeightsSaw this at Peckhamplex on Valentine's week, which felt deeply unhinged. Heathcliff is supposed to be a nightmare, not a heartthrob, Emily would have words.Wuthering Heights (2026)Book, obviously95A Rye Lane, LondonLondon
2Dune: Part TwoHerbert's prose is a slog honestly (sorry, sci-fi nerds) and Villeneuve somehow made the sandworms more terrifying than my imagination ever managed.Dune: Part TwoFilm, don't @ me95A Rye Lane, LondonLondon
3The Wild RobotDragged a very reluctant friend to this expecting a kids' cash-grab and we both cried in public. Mortifying. The book's sparer but the film earns its sentimentality.The Wild RobotTie, annoyingly95A Rye Lane, LondonLondon
4WickedTechnically the Gregory Maguire novel is the source, but let's be honest nobody's reading that when they could be watching Cynthia Erivo levitate.WickedMusical, not really either95A Rye Lane, LondonLondon