City crushes
List · 9 items

City crushes

Marcus HsuMarcus Hsu · 1 like
9 items
ListCities · Places/Travel

City crushes

Marcus Hsu
@marcusmetrics
9Items
1Likes

Boston and I are in a long-term relationship, but I definitely have side-crushes on other cities. This is my running short list of places I compare everything to — some are bigger, some are weirder, some are just better at brunch — but all of them scratch a different itch. Half data brain (stats, transit, housing) and half vibes (does this place feel like a pickup run that got out of hand or a Sunday crossword with buildings).

The list

Rank
City crushes — 9 items
NameCountryVibe in one lineRough population sizeTransit / getting aroundMy take
1BostonUnited StatesHistory nerd in running shoes who accidentally learned to like good food.About 650k in the city; ~5M in the metro.T is creaky but covers the basics; insanely walkable core; bike network getting less terrifying each year.Still my baseline city: high ceiling on walkable neighborhoods and low ceiling on winter happiness. Feels like a college campus that turned into a whole metro area.
2New York CityUnited StatesMain character energy turned into a five-borough shared delusion.About 8.5M in the city; ~20M in the metro.Subway is chaotic but omnipresent; you can live car-free and still forget what a steering wheel looks like.Every time I visit I decide to move there for exactly 36 hours, then see rent prices and scuttle back to Boston like a crab with student loans.
3ChicagoUnited StatesBig-shouldered extrovert who actually remembers your name.Roughly 2.7M in the city; ~9.5M in the metro.L is solid in the core, buses fill in the grid, and the city actually understands what a bike lane is.Feels like the Midwest built a proper coastal city as a group project. If you fused Boston’s density with friendlier people and cheaper rents, you’d get something suspiciously Chicago-shaped.
4MontrealCanadaEuropean weekend packed into a North American body with poutine in both hands.About 1.8M in the city; ~4.3M in the metro.Metro is clean and logical, biking is fantastic in warm months, and walking + cafés is basically the local religion.My favorite "I need to feel like I traveled far without actually doing that" city. Perfect for pretending you’re sophisticated while still paying in dollars that mostly feel like dollars.
5Portland (Maine)United StatesChill coastal town that min-maxed food and scenery instead of size.About 70k in the city; ~500k in the metro.Walkable downtown and waterfront; buses exist but this is mostly a feet-and-uber type situation.My go-to escape hatch when Boston feels loud. Great beer, ridiculous seafood, and the kind of streets that make you consider buying a notebook and becoming “a writer.”
6SeattleUnited StatesTech wizard in a fleece who power-walks between coffee and trailheads.Around 750k in the city; ~4.1M in the metro.Light rail is finally useful, buses are solid, and hills make you earn every walkability point.Feels like Boston’s outdoorsy cousin who discovered microdosing and better mountain views. I could absolutely live here if I ever start taking vitamin D seriously.
7AustinUnited StatesLive-music extrovert trapped in a rapidly sprouting tech campus.Roughly 980k in the city; ~2.5M in the metro.Bus-heavy and car-heavy; light rail is a work in progress, so rideshares are doing a lot of cardio.Every time I’m there I bounce between “this is a playground” and “this is what happens when zoning laws take a nap.” Elite tacos, questionable summers, vibes off the charts.
8CopenhagenDenmarkMinimalist fairy tale where bikes outnumber bad design choices.About 650k in the city; roughly 1.4M in the metro.Bikes rule everything; metro is clean and frequent; walking feels like touring a Scandinavian UX demo.This is my urban-planning crush. Whenever Boston adds a new bike lane, I’m like, “Look at you, trying to be Copenhagen when you grow up.”
9TokyoJapanHyper-dense fever dream that’s somehow the most orderly chaos on Earth.Roughly 14M in the 23 wards; around 37M in the greater metro.Transit system is a literal boss battle of complexity but runs like a perfectly timed speedrun; walking is endless micro-neighborhood discovery.If you like cities as systems, this is the final level. Every time I read about Tokyo I want to print transit maps and hang them like posters above my bed, which is a normal thing that normal people do.